16 Comments
User's avatar
X. P. Callahan's avatar

Blurbs are kind of a joke. But my little imprint is putting out a chapbook by an early-career poet this spring, and I thought it was fair to him if he/I asked for blurbs from other poets. Just for the sake of appearances. So we did. But I would be happy to see the practice end.

Expand full comment
Lev Raphael's avatar

I won't name names but one publisher of mine asked a famous author to blurb one of my novels because she and I had corresponded. Said author said she was against the whole process. My editor thought she was a hypocrite because this author's first book was boosted by a Nobel Prize winner. My mother would have had choice nouns to use. :-)

Expand full comment
Richard Donnelly's avatar

"to the point where the blurbs can’t be trusted" There's no point where blurbs could be trusted. Blurbs are advertising, nothing more.

I'd be surprised if blurbs vanish. Advertising on packaging works, whether books, cereal, electric razors, what have you.

Expand full comment
Lev Raphael's avatar

They could be trusted back before everyone was a genius, every book was brilliant.

Expand full comment
Richard Donnelly's avatar

Ha! I don't think there was ever a negative book blurb Lev

Expand full comment
Liz Gauffreau's avatar

I have been asked to write blurbs, and I've always said no for the simple reason that I can't figure out how to write them. (I offer to write an actual review instead.) When I read a blurb, particularly if it's for a poetry collection, I can't understand what the heck the blurb actually means.

Expand full comment
Lev Raphael's avatar

Back when I was reviewing for a handful of publications and also on-air, I'd tell people that if I liked the book, a review would be more helpful. But I often didn't have the time to even do a blurb and if that was the case, I told them ASAP so they could look for someone else.

Expand full comment
Liz Gauffreau's avatar

I'm still on the fence about whether I should ask for blurbs for my novel coming out in October.

Expand full comment
Lev Raphael's avatar

Can you use review quotes from other books, as in "Praise for Liz Gaffreau"?

Expand full comment
Liz Gauffreau's avatar

Great idea! Thank you for the suggestion.

Expand full comment
Richard Donnelly's avatar

I almost never see books at Barnes and Noble without blurbs. For that reason alone I would include them.

Expand full comment
Liz Gauffreau's avatar

Thank you, Richard. I’m still dithering . . .

Expand full comment
Susan Oleksiw's avatar

As someone who is often asked for a blurb, I'm glad to see the practice come to an end. If I like a book I'm glad to say so, but finding something that is both honest and compelling for prospective readers is work. I'm glad not to have to ask anyone for my books and glad that I may not have to give any again.

Expand full comment
Lev Raphael's avatar

My 27th book came out before the pandemic and once isolation set in as a mode of living, I found much more delight working with short stories and personal essays. I've had something like 95 online and print publications since the summer of 2021. It feels great.

Expand full comment
Ernie Brill's avatar

Dont throw the baby out with the bathwater. For my first book of poetry Journeys of Voices and Choices (Wendell, MA, Human Error Press,2024) I had five enticing blurbs, especially two that have helped sell my book. One or five ass-kissing blurbs on a book by an overrated writer does should not make a policy of endng blurbs. I also had several terrific blurbs for my first book -I Looked Over Jordan And Other Stories"(Boston:South End Press,1980) from the legendary blacklisted Minnesotan feminist Meridel LeSueur, author of the Girl and Ripenings, and from Dan Georgakas,cofounder of Cineaste Magazine, and author of Detroit I Do Mind Dying, and The Methuselah Factor.

Expand full comment
User's avatar
Comment deleted
Feb 26
Comment deleted
Expand full comment
Lev Raphael's avatar

Amen. I've always preferred recycling book reviewer's pull-quotes, especially from the NYTBR.

Expand full comment